As an owner-operator or other employee with the critical role of helping manage commercial fleets, ensuring compliance with federal regulations is crucial to avoiding costly fines, maintaining a good safety record, and protecting your company's reputation. However, navigating the complex landscape of compliance requirements can be challenging, and even experienced managers can make critical mistakes. In this article, we'll explore the top five compliance mistakes made by commercial fleet operators who are federally regulated and discuss how to avoid these pitfalls.
Mistake #1: Inadequate Driver Qualification File Management
One of the most significant compliance mistakes commercial fleet managers make is failing to properly maintain driver qualification files (DQFs). DQFs are critical documents that contain information about a driver's qualifications, including their license, medical certification, and employment history. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) requires that DQFs be accurate, complete, and up-to-date. Defining a clear process for creating and proactively managing your files or leveraging specialized DQF management software to do so will help ensure compliance.
On-demand Webinar: 9 Expert Tips for Managing Driver Qualification Files
Mistake #2: Insufficient Drug and Alcohol Testing
Another common compliance mistake is inadequate drug and alcohol testing. The FMCSA requires that commercial drivers be subject to regular drug and alcohol testing, including pre-employment, random, post-accident, and return-to-duty tests. That's a lot to keep up with. Many successful fleet managers outsource their drug and alcohol testing program management to external partners who can take this burden off their plates and ensure there are no costly mistakes.
Related Blog Post: DOT Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse Compliance Basics
Mistake #3: Failure to Monitor Driver Safety Data
Commercial fleet managers often overlook the importance of or don't have the time to proactively monitor driver safety data, which can lead to unnoticed safety issues and increased risk. Today's leading CSA data monitoring software provides safety and fleet managers with greater visibility and enables quicker responses to any issues. In a single platform, you can track your driver and risk data in real-time, and receive alerts on crashes, inspections, and violations for every driver. This allows you to identify potential safety issues early and take proactive steps to mitigate risk.
On-demand Webinar: Understanding CSA Data & How It Works
Mistake #4: Inaccurate or Incomplete FMCSA Clearinghouse Queries
The FMCSA Clearinghouse is a critical tool for ensuring compliance with drug and alcohol testing regulations. However, many commercial fleet managers struggle to accurately and completely query the Clearinghouse, which can lead to compliance issues. Fleet managers must either become experts on this task or work with a trusted Third-Party Administrator (TPA) to run FMCSA Clearinghouse Compliance queries and report drug and alcohol violations on their behalf.
Free Guide: Queries & Consents: Everything You Need to Know About DOT Clearinghouse Recordkeeping
Mistake #5: Inadequate Motor Vehicle Record (MVR) Monitoring
Finally, commercial fleet managers often fail to properly monitor their drivers' motor vehicle records (MVRs), which can lead to unnoticed safety issues and increased risk. MVR monitoring is a critical part of a driver safety program that can help you identify high-risk candidates and drivers, fulfill annual DOT MVR check requirements, reduce your company's risk profile, and comply with state and federal regulations. The best MVR monitoring software alerts you when a driver receives a new violation, license suspension, or other reportable event, enabling you to respond quickly and reduce risk across your fleet.
Learn more: Why Continuous MVR Monitoring Isn't Optional for Employers in 2025
Knowledge is Power
By understanding common compliance mistakes, fleet operators and their teams can develop strategic, proactive programs that meet their specific needs and identify potential gaps in their existing safety plans. Foley's comprehensive suite of compliance solutions can help you stay on top of your compliance obligations, from driver qualification file management to drug and alcohol testing, safety data monitoring, FMCSA Clearinghouse queries, and MVR monitoring. By leveraging Foley's expertise and technology, you can mitigate risk, improve safety, and drive business success, whether you're a small fleet or a large enterprise. We are here to help you achieve a safer, more efficient, and more successful fleet management operation.
See our platform in action.
.png)